gfhockeyrules wrote:Here are the selections:
G - Seth Lang GFC
G - Scott Bucholz FS
D - Ryan Hills - Grafton
D - Danny Luecke - FS
D - Josh Hooey - FS
D - David Burdick - FS
D - Danny Ray - GFC
F - Russell Crary - RR
F - Jacob LaDouceur - RR
F - Tanner Spicer - GFC
F - Justin Moody - GFC
F - Casey Purpur - GFC
F - Alex Gaustad - Grafton
F - Cody Boyle - Grafton
F - Ryan Mohagen - Grafton
F - Peter Orson - FS
I have listed below the other players, I would argue that are just as or more deserving than some of the ones selected, and here some questions to ponder...
1. Four players from a 4th place team?
2. Three Defenseman(out of 5) from Fargo South?
3. Coaches not voting for players, with hidden agendas against them?
4. Previous year should not be a factor.
G - Chris Stokke - Shanley
D - Luke Cieklinski - GFC
D - Derek Sand - WF
F - Grant Narveson - FS
F - Cooper Stellrecht - FS
F - Jordan Bancroft - RR
F - Jake Plutowski - GFC
F - Jordan Aamot - GFC
F - Jake McPhail - FN
gfhockeyrules wrote:I have listed below the other players, I would argue that are just as or more deserving than some of the ones selected, and here some questions to ponder...
1. Four players from a 4th place team?
2. Three Defenseman(out of 5) from Fargo South?
3. Coaches not voting for players, with hidden agendas against them?
4. Previous year should not be a factor.
toews19 wrote:take the minnesota twins for example. it seems like they are a good team every year and have a chance to win their division every year, yet they only have 2 or 3 all stars every year. just because a team doesnt have many "all-stars" doesnt me they cant be a good team. although i do think some players were left off the list that should have been on there.
SportsDoc wrote:All State is picked by the coaches.
HockeyHigh wrote:You really can't get by this, and it won't change. Having a quality relationship with your coach is part of getting these rewards. On the other hand, having a bad one can cause you to go unappreciated for these awards.
BLJELW wrote:I thought the worst decision of the All EDC team was to pick seth lang as there goalie...arguably Stokke is the best goalie in the State and he didnt make the all EDC Team after holding his own against South who nearly put 50 shots on him...If he was on RR, CENTRAL, GPR, OR South he would have a way better save percentage and would have made the all EDC team...I don't think the teams record should affect the EDC team which is individually chosen.
Centralhockey_08 wrote:BLJELW wrote:I thought the worst decision of the All EDC team was to pick seth lang as there goalie...arguably Stokke is the best goalie in the State and he didnt make the all EDC Team after holding his own against South who nearly put 50 shots on him...If he was on RR, CENTRAL, GPR, OR South he would have a way better save percentage and would have made the all EDC team...I don't think the teams record should affect the EDC team which is individually chosen.
You have got to be kidding me, are you serious?
BLJELW wrote: I thought the worst decision of the All EDC team was to pick seth lang as there goalie...arguably Stokke is the best goalie in the State and he didnt make the all EDC Team after holding his own against South who nearly put 50 shots on him...If he was on RR, CENTRAL, GPR, OR South he would have a way better save percentage and would have made the all EDC team...I don't think the teams record should affect the EDC team which is individually chosen.
Centralhockey_08 wrote:BLJELW wrote: I thought the worst decision of the All EDC team was to pick seth lang as there goalie...arguably Stokke is the best goalie in the State and he didnt make the all EDC Team after holding his own against South who nearly put 50 shots on him...If he was on RR, CENTRAL, GPR, OR South he would have a way better save percentage and would have made the all EDC team...I don't think the teams record should affect the EDC team which is individually chosen.
If he was on those three teams he wouldn't even be playing. That is a poor argument.
sweeper wrote:Centralhockey_08 wrote:BLJELW wrote: I thought the worst decision of the All EDC team was to pick seth lang as there goalie...arguably Stokke is the best goalie in the State and he didnt make the all EDC Team after holding his own against South who nearly put 50 shots on him...If he was on RR, CENTRAL, GPR, OR South he would have a way better save percentage and would have made the all EDC team...I don't think the teams record should affect the EDC team which is individually chosen.
If he was on those three teams he wouldn't even be playing. That is a poor argument.
Agreed, Freidig from DL held his own against South having 52 saves in the 6-0 loss. But if he were on some of these other teams he probably would have not hardly had any playing time. It is about what you can do for YOUR TEAM. Not about what you could possibly do on another team. So why worry about what could have been?
12345 wrote:IMO it would be if LaDoucer didnt have Crary would he have half as many points as he does now...
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest