My opinion.
Each class should have a player of the year.
There should be one Mr. Basketball open to all classes.
My biggest problem with the Mr. Basketball award is it is voted on before the State B championship game. I think sometimes the media sees a class A player lead there school to a state title and gets some votes he wouldn't not have got. Now a class B player can't do that because the votes are in before the B championship game.
Why they give out senior athlete of the year is just dumb imo, especially a sport like girls track, when some girl might win 4 events as freshman, but can't get the award until she is a senior and by that time she might not even be that good.