gophers18 wrote:Is this list in a newspaper? seems odd that it is out so late and who voted on this? none of the coaches in southeast ND knew about an all state team. just wondering then if it is legit.
scc wrote:Hinsa wrote:gophers18 wrote:Is this list in a newspaper? seems odd that it is out so late and who voted on this? none of the coaches in southeast ND knew about an all state team. just wondering then if it is legit.
I would really like to know where this list came from as well - NDHSAA? Sportswriters?
And 3 Guys from Ryan??? No Holen? Doesn't seem like this was very well done.
The award is not affiliated with the NDHSAA or the sportscasters and sportswriters.
baseball11 wrote:Doesn't James Olderbak play class A in Devils Lake?
baseball wrote:scc wrote:Hinsa wrote:gophers18 wrote:Is this list in a newspaper? seems odd that it is out so late and who voted on this? none of the coaches in southeast ND knew about an all state team. just wondering then if it is legit.
I would really like to know where this list came from as well - NDHSAA? Sportswriters?
And 3 Guys from Ryan??? No Holen? Doesn't seem like this was very well done.
The award is not affiliated with the NDHSAA or the sportscasters and sportswriters.
So.....baseball4life is the one who made the list or what?
baseball wrote:Who voted for the list tho is the question. if its not with the NDHSAA, sportscasters, or sportswriters, who is it? coaches? and someone posted there were coaches in some areas of the state who didnt even know about it so i doubt it was a coaches vote.
cubsfan wrote:baseball wrote:Who voted for the list tho is the question. if its not with the NDHSAA, sportscasters, or sportswriters, who is it? coaches? and someone posted there were coaches in some areas of the state who didnt even know about it so i doubt it was a coaches vote.
I believe it was the coaches who voted on it. There were some names that shouldn't have been their and some names that were left off.
cubsfan wrote:baseball wrote:Who voted for the list tho is the question. if its not with the NDHSAA, sportscasters, or sportswriters, who is it? coaches? and someone posted there were coaches in some areas of the state who didnt even know about it so i doubt it was a coaches vote.
I believe it was the coaches who voted on it. There were some names that shouldn't have been their and some names that were left off.
baseball4life wrote:cubsfan wrote:baseball wrote:Who voted for the list tho is the question. if its not with the NDHSAA, sportscasters, or sportswriters, who is it? coaches? and someone posted there were coaches in some areas of the state who didnt even know about it so i doubt it was a coaches vote.
I believe it was the coaches who voted on it. There were some names that shouldn't have been their and some names that were left off.
I though that it was a fairly legit list but that is my opinion. in your opinion who would you take off and who would you put on?
ndfootball06 wrote:I got a chance to watch him at the East West game and how he hit .750 and was Senior Player of the Year is beyond me.
jtdc492 wrote:Batting .750 is still batting .750, and that was over the season, not one all star game. I'm not here to defend Blake Kaul, but come on, give the guy his due. Oh, and how do you skew statistics? Either he did it or he didn't. Weak region? Maybe- he still had to get hits. Is he as big and powerful as Kliniske? Obviously not, more consistent at the plate? Probably.
baseball wrote:jtdc492 wrote:Batting .750 is still batting .750, and that was over the season, not one all star game. I'm not here to defend Blake Kaul, but come on, give the guy his due. Oh, and how do you skew statistics? Either he did it or he didn't. Weak region? Maybe- he still had to get hits. Is he as big and powerful as Kliniske? Obviously not, more consistent at the plate? Probably.
course of 30 games its possible...just like a 3 point shooter who shot 60% but only took 10 attempts. all depends on how the person keeps the book too. theres coaches who wont give you a hit unless its a solid line drive and a legit hit while some other would give you a hit as long as you touch the ball with the bat and get on base. again, im NOT saying hes bad because hes not, im just saying hes not the best in the state and I think everyone who saw him, Backas, and Kilinske, they will tell you its no comparison.
jtdc492 wrote:If you take Blake Kaul off who do you put on to replace him? Somebody from Steele?
ndsportsfan98 wrote:The Enderlin tournament didn't even take place this spring because of bad weather. I would put Ben Watkins from Lamoure on the list before i'd put on Ben Holen.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests