ndlionsfan wrote:It looks like Region 3 still goes by a hard line for the number of players chosen to all region based on how the team finished. Doesn't look like Region 2 did this. Kinda sad that an allstate player isn't even on the allregion team.
panthercub wrote:ndlionsfan wrote:It looks like Region 3 still goes by a hard line for the number of players chosen to all region based on how the team finished. Doesn't look like Region 2 did this. Kinda sad that an allstate player isn't even on the allregion team.
Who was missing that was an all stater?
d_fense wrote:ndlionsfan,.
if a player does not make all region, their coach has no business putting him up for all state.
dyhardballa09 wrote:d_fense wrote:ndlionsfan,.
if a player does not make all region, their coach has no business putting him up for all state.
What if a coach has 3 all-region selections based on the number he gets for that spot and he feels like he has 4 or 5 all-state caliber players? Its not his fault for who gets voted in.
What if a player is a one-way player (i.e. kirk degenstein), and that one-way player was top 5 in state at his position. But, you only get 3 all-region picks, and you have 8 2-way starters to also pick from. Some coaches go with the two-way player over the one-way player. I don't know who the all-stater not on all-region was, but it may be a situation like this. The coach probably had a good reason.....I hope
Also, a guy like Degenstein will be very hard to get on the all-state team, because he is competing with Schwartz, Hagler, Schweitzer, Bell, Hardy and Young at QB. So, theoritically, one of MLS's HM's may have a better chance at all-state, even though Degenstein meant more to the team and earned all-region.
panthercub wrote:I think Drew Schill deserves at LEAST honorable mention if not all region at db! IMO He was the best tackler on the NS squad!
AF PN wrote:For NS Did Josh Haugen make it for Offensive or Defensive End??
dyhardballa09 wrote:I don't see who Stoll would replace on all-region for BC tho...yes he made all-state, but i'm sure those other kids got at least nominated for all-state. Now, if you look at those other 3 players, their positions were lineman, or linebackers. Lots of nominations at those two positions from around the state. Then stoll at WR probably, not many teams have all-state caliber WR. So, I think it is easier to have a good year and make all-state at WR than have a good year and make it at LB or Lineman. I think every player on all-state should have all-region, but I just dont see any of those 4 seniors not getting all-region. young was senior or year. Knutson was all-region last year and their best lineman. Urness and Knudson were their top two RBs and top two LBs. I belive they were 1 and 2 in tackles on team. I think that those other 3 may be better players, but just faced stiffer competition when it comes to all-state selection.
Bearcats13 wrote:I don't see how haugen got all region, once he got hurt he didnt do anything the rest of the season. I think he got in there because his dad was the coach. IMO I dont see how he got in there. Vball10 I dont see why it would matter how many years Schill played or not the region team is picked off of this years performance isnt it?
Bearcats13 wrote:I don't see how haugen got all region, once he got hurt he didnt do anything the rest of the season. I think he got in there because his dad was the coach. IMO I dont see how he got in there. Vball10 I dont see why it would matter how many years Schill played or not the region team is picked off of this years performance isnt it?
Bison-Vikes #1 wrote:Bearcats13 wrote:I don't see how haugen got all region, once he got hurt he didnt do anything the rest of the season. I think he got in there because his dad was the coach. IMO I dont see how he got in there. Vball10 I dont see why it would matter how many years Schill played or not the region team is picked off of this years performance isnt it?
C'mon. Followed every Bearcat game this year. Haugen being a coach's son had no bearing on his selection. Josh started the year on a torrid pace against some of the toughest teams in their regular season schedule. Even after he came back from his bad injury, he played above average at about 75% health wise.
Schill started the season a little slow. Probably because he had to sit out all last year with an injury. But as he got more comfortable in the scheme of things, he really started to shine at the end of the season. Really a solid tackler. Had some awesome games during the playoffs.
The bottom line is the Bearcats went as far as they did because they had good athletes all over that team, including reserves. It's unfortunate that a line has to be drawn, because some really good players are going to get left off. IMO, that's what happened this time.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests