Page 1 of 2

Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 4:04 pm
by NDHSF
Rank the preseason Top 5 Division AA teams.

I put a site together for 11-man North Dakota High School football. www.northdakotahsfootball.blogspot.com

I'd like your help in ranking the teams in each Division.

Thank you.

Doug

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Aug 24, 2009 10:33 pm
by Run4Fun2009
1. Wahpeton
2. Devils Lake
3. Bismarck St. Marys
4. Fargo Shanley
5. Lisbon

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Tue Aug 25, 2009 10:41 am
by cubsfan
Run4Fun2009 wrote:1. Wahpeton
2. Devils Lake
3. Bismarck St. Marys
4. Fargo Shanley
5. Lisbon

I think Lisbon will struggle this year. They lost most of their lineman from last year and starting qb Josh Nims.

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 2:41 pm
by tweener
Run4Fun2009 wrote:1. Wahpeton
2. Devils Lake
3. Bismarck St. Marys
4. Fargo Shanley
5. Lisbon


Devils Lake, on Friday, play VC so we should see what they have as far as expectations for the # 2 spot. I know its speculation, But how can we not have Watford City on the list here? Did they go to A?

I do agree with Wahpeton being the team to beat, but dont think they are unbeatable. Havent ever seen St Mary's play so this should be interesting for the two battling it out. Lisbon should be better than 5 I think, did they lose many of the stars from last year?

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 3:29 pm
by Run4Fun2009
tweener wrote:
Run4Fun2009 wrote:1. Wahpeton
2. Devils Lake
3. Bismarck St. Marys
4. Fargo Shanley
5. Lisbon


Devils Lake, on Friday, play VC so we should see what they have as far as expectations for the # 2 spot. I know its speculation, But how can we not have Watford City on the list here? Did they go to A?

I do agree with Wahpeton being the team to beat, but dont think they are unbeatable. Havent ever seen St Mary's play so this should be interesting for the two battling it out. Lisbon should be better than 5 I think, did they lose many of the stars from last year?


k...well Watford City is A and Lisbon lost a few star players from last year's team; but they always compete well with a good defense. We'll know more after this weekend!

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Wed Aug 26, 2009 9:52 pm
by cubsfan
Lisbon lost at least three starting defensive lineman and a couple of their linebackers too. It will take a while for these new kids to get adjusted. Their offensive line will not be nearly as big as they lose two shrine bowlers in Brent Durkin and Jordan Stenson.

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Thu Aug 27, 2009 12:09 pm
by football101
The top two are both to high. Smith is a horse but he can't do it by himself. DL is one injury away from going .500. DL will be a three or four seed going into the playoffs

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Fri Aug 28, 2009 12:35 pm
by baseball18
1. Wahpeton
2. St. Marys
3. DL
4. Shanley
5. Bottineau

St. Marys prolly has the best QB in all of AA in Justin Klabunde, he's a dual threat QB and they also have some good skill position players with Ryan Huber, Drew Carlson, and Jon Welk, all got speed. Should be a great game tonight vs. Wahp

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Fri Sep 11, 2009 9:28 pm
by ClassBEast
I think you all need to start considering Central Cass. They blew out Oak Grove (26 - 0) and only lost to Wahpeton by 1 (14 - 13).

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Fri Sep 11, 2009 9:41 pm
by Run4Fun2009
ClassBEast wrote:I think you all need to start considering Central Cass. They blew out Oak Grove (26 - 0) and only lost to Wahpeton by 1 (14 - 13).


They should get some consideration now!

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Sat Sep 12, 2009 8:40 am
by Number_2
cubsfan wrote:
Run4Fun2009 wrote:1. Wahpeton
2. Devils Lake
3. Bismarck St. Marys
4. Fargo Shanley
5. Lisbon

I think Lisbon will struggle this year. They lost most of their lineman from last year and starting qb Josh Nims.

yah but dont forget lisbon also had two different starting qbs last year and the other one is still here...adam coykendal

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Sun Sep 13, 2009 6:51 pm
by Run4Fun2009
My rankings after Week #3

1. Devils Lake (3-0)
2. Wahpeton (3-0)
3. Lisbon (3-0)
4. Dickinson Trinity (3-0)
5. Fargo Shanley (2-1)

Other Recieving Votes: Central Cass (2-1)

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Sun Sep 13, 2009 11:32 pm
by ndsportsfan14
1. Wahpeton (3-0)
2. Devils Lake (3-0)
3. Dickinson Trinity (3-0)
4. Central Cass (2-1)
5. Lisbon (3-0)

Other Recieving Votes: Fargo Shanley (2-1)

That would be mine..

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 14, 2009 9:44 am
by Run4Fun2009
ndsportsfan14 wrote:1. Wahpeton (3-0)
2. Devils Lake (3-0)
3. Dickinson Trinity (3-0)
4. Central Cass (2-1)
5. Lisbon (3-0)

Other Recieving Votes: Fargo Shanley (2-1)

That would be mine..


Well that would be the first time I would have seen a team move up after losing :)

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 14, 2009 12:59 pm
by ND_beast
Run4Fun2009 wrote:
ndsportsfan14 wrote:1. Wahpeton (3-0)
2. Devils Lake (3-0)
3. Dickinson Trinity (3-0)
4. Central Cass (2-1)
5. Lisbon (3-0)

Other Recieving Votes: Fargo Shanley (2-1)

That would be mine..


Well that would be the first time I would have seen a team move up after losing :)

That's true that doesn't happen very much, but Central Cass is the only team to score on Wahpeton (13 pts), and Wahpeton is the only team to score on Central Cass (14 pts), this year and CC played them very well to the point they could have won the games in a few instances. I think that voters should look at strength of schedule and how games have been played against stronger teams. I don't believe that CC should be that high but they probally should be thought about for at least 5. I would be very suprised, as would a lot of others, if Central Cass falls off because they lost.

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 14, 2009 1:43 pm
by Run4Fun2009
ND_beast wrote:
Run4Fun2009 wrote:
ndsportsfan14 wrote:1. Wahpeton (3-0)
2. Devils Lake (3-0)
3. Dickinson Trinity (3-0)
4. Central Cass (2-1)
5. Lisbon (3-0)

Other Recieving Votes: Fargo Shanley (2-1)

That would be mine..


Well that would be the first time I would have seen a team move up after losing :)

That's true that doesn't happen very much, but Central Cass is the only team to score on Wahpeton (13 pts), and Wahpeton is the only team to score on Central Cass (14 pts), this year and CC played them very well to the point they could have won the games in a few instances. I think that voters should look at strength of schedule and how games have been played against stronger teams. I don't believe that CC should be that high but they probally should be thought about for at least 5. I would be very suprised, as would a lot of others, if Central Cass falls off because they lost.


In the actual STATE poll from last week CC wasn't even in the Top 5 (see below)

"Class 2A
1. Wahpeton (10) 2-0 50 1
2. Devils Lake 2-0 38 2
3. Dickinson Trinity 2-0 31 3
4. Lisbon 2-0 20 5
5. Fargo Shanley 1-1 6 NR
Also receiving votes: Central Cass (2-0) 2, Bismarck St.Mary’s (0-2) 2, Grafton (1-1) 1"

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 14, 2009 2:09 pm
by digger
It was only a matter of time before the Central Cass football program started clicking; a large school with good athletic tradition in other sports, there is no reason they shouldn't have a strong football program. The Squirrels played a terrific game against the Huskies, just a year or two ago it would have been considered crazy talk to say that Central Cass could have competed with Wahpeton in football. This year is just a step (a significant step) towards what should be a perrenially strong football team.

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 14, 2009 3:26 pm
by baseball18
My rankings

1. Wahpeton (3-0)
2. Devils Lake (3-0)
3. Lisbon (3-0)
4. Fargo Shanley (2-1)
5. Dickinson Trinity (3-0)

Also Receiving Votes: Central Cass (2-1), St. Mary's (1-2)

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 14, 2009 7:18 pm
by gobison#6
digger wrote:It was only a matter of time before the Central Cass football program started clicking; a large school with good athletic tradition in other sports, there is no reason they shouldn't have a strong football program. The Squirrels played a terrific game against the Huskies, just a year or two ago it would have been considered crazy talk to say that Central Cass could have competed with Wahpeton in football. This year is just a step (a significant step) towards what should be a perrenially strong football team.

This year's senior class at CC has tried very hard in their careers and are pushing the younger guys. The team has grown slightly in the past few years and has gotten a lot better. This year I noticed the CC football team has t shirts that say Central Cass Football Starting a Tradition. This senior class has been waiting for this season.

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Sat Sep 19, 2009 7:16 pm
by gobison#6
my rankings after week 4

1. Devils Lake
2. Wahpeton
3. Lisbon
4. Dickinson Trinity
5. Central Cass

I would say Shanley is my number 6 team

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Sun Sep 20, 2009 10:25 pm
by Run4Fun2009
gobison#6 wrote:my rankings after week 4

1. Devils Lake
2. Wahpeton
3. Lisbon
4. Dickinson Trinity
5. Central Cass

I would say Shanley is my number 6 team


Lisbon may be undefeated...but they aren't as good as their rankings would suggest!

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 21, 2009 8:10 pm
by gobison#6
Run4Fun2009 wrote:
gobison#6 wrote:my rankings after week 4

1. Devils Lake
2. Wahpeton
3. Lisbon
4. Dickinson Trinity
5. Central Cass

I would say Shanley is my number 6 team


Lisbon may be undefeated...but they aren't as good as their rankings would suggest!

Lisbon has a very good running back in Schell and a good tradition of being a great football team though.

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Mon Sep 21, 2009 8:15 pm
by ndfan
I would go right now.

1. Devils Lake
2. Wahpeton
3. Dickinson Trinity
4. Central Cass
5. Lisbon

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Tue Sep 22, 2009 9:28 am
by utilityman
The polls that came out today have Lisbon and Shanley in it with Central Cass honorable mention. I think Central Cass is better than Lisbon and Shanley. They only lost by 1 point to Wahpeton. Also, Valley City has been playing very good lately and I think they will def. beat Lisbon. One thing to look at with Valley City is they've skunked Oak Grove and Kindred in back to back weeks, while Lisbon only beat Oak Grove by 3.

Central Cass and VC aren't getting much respect but thats prob alright with them.

Re: Rank 'em

PostPosted: Tue Sep 22, 2009 10:03 am
by ClassBEast
utilityman wrote:The polls that came out today have Lisbon and Shanley in it with Central Cass honorable mention. I think Central Cass is better than Lisbon and Shanley. They only lost by 1 point to Wahpeton. Also, Valley City has been playing very good lately and I think they will def. beat Lisbon. One thing to look at with Valley City is they've skunked Oak Grove and Kindred in back to back weeks, while Lisbon only beat Oak Grove by 3.

Central Cass and VC aren't getting much respect but thats prob alright with them.


Central Cass plays Shanley on Friday so it will be great to see how that goes. Should be a good game!