cast3 wrote:parochial schools should have to play in the class A
cast3 wrote:parochial schools should have to play in the class A
heimer wrote:Too bad run. Talent pool of 100000+ means more than your technical enrollment.
Learn a lesson
heimer wrote:No districts smart a--. 100000 is low, considering that they could come in from all over the country. But, since you're such a smart guy, I'll clarify by stating that one school is in a community where the talent pool is drawn from over 130000 permanent residents.
dukefan32 wrote:I've got an idea.... Why don't they just give every team a trophy.... Then everybody wins.
Get real Heimer. No private school gets to pick any athlete out of a talent pool.
heimer wrote:dukefan32 wrote:I've got an idea.... Why don't they just give every team a trophy.... Then everybody wins.
Get real Heimer. No private school gets to pick any athlete out of a talent pool.
It's sad, really. I'm so bad at this compared to private school fans. I have to work really hard and try to make myself look sound like an apologist in denial, without a single ounce of intelligence. Private school apologists don't even have to try. It comes so natural.
heimer wrote:Quite correct, and by comparison, a Class "B" town of 1000 people, a middle-to-big Class "B" town by today's standards, would have a talent pool of, by your percentage, 200.
So, 200 to 26,000. Good comparison.
The bleeding hearts from the privates cannot deny that there are plenty of advantages to where they are located, regardless of the technical enrollment comparisons. This bull about "walking the halls" is pure crap. Numbers don't lie.
dukefan32 wrote:heimer wrote:dukefan32 wrote:I've got an idea.... Why don't they just give every team a trophy.... Then everybody wins.
Get real Heimer. No private school gets to pick any athlete out of a talent pool.
It's sad, really. I'm so bad at this compared to private school fans. I have to work really hard and try to make myself look sound like an apologist in denial, without a single ounce of intelligence. Private school apologists don't even have to try. It comes so natural.
The reason why it's so natural is because that's all we hear as a private school. We don't hear, "Man that Trinity/Ryan/ETC team is good. Those boys must have been playing together for awhile." We hear, "Well lets see who they recruited this year. Oh, so and so wasn't on the team last year, must have came from the public school." I would love to see you be a parent or an athlete at a private school, because some of the stuff that's said is just rediculous.
Bisonguy06 wrote:dukefan32 wrote:heimer wrote:dukefan32 wrote:I've got an idea.... Why don't they just give every team a trophy.... Then everybody wins.
Get real Heimer. No private school gets to pick any athlete out of a talent pool.
It's sad, really. I'm so bad at this compared to private school fans. I have to work really hard and try to make myself look sound like an apologist in denial, without a single ounce of intelligence. Private school apologists don't even have to try. It comes so natural.
The reason why it's so natural is because that's all we hear as a private school. We don't hear, "Man that Trinity/Ryan/ETC team is good. Those boys must have been playing together for awhile." We hear, "Well lets see who they recruited this year. Oh, so and so wasn't on the team last year, must have came from the public school." I would love to see you be a parent or an athlete at a private school, because some of the stuff that's said is just rediculous.
Don't waste your time with heimer. He has an ax to grind. There are plenty of good kids and good stories at the B this year as always. Root for your team, respect the others, and turn the other cheek.
winner-within wrote:I agree, Dickinson Trinity, Bishop Ryan, Oak Grove and such, along with Valley City they should all be in Class A and stay there until they get to 100 or less total in HS, then it would equal things out to the 150 to 200's drawing from 1,000 to 2,000 people....Great point, great analysis!
winner-within wrote:I agree, Dickinson Trinity, Bishop Ryan, Oak Grove and such, along with Valley City they should all be in Class A and stay there until they get to 100 or less total in HS, then it would equal things out to the 150 to 200's drawing from 1,000 to 2,000 people....Great point, great analysis!
ndfan wrote:winner-within wrote:I agree, Dickinson Trinity, Bishop Ryan, Oak Grove and such, along with Valley City they should all be in Class A and stay there until they get to 100 or less total in HS, then it would equal things out to the 150 to 200's drawing from 1,000 to 2,000 people....Great point, great analysis!
Might as well just shut down the school if they get 100 or less kids.
Johhnyping wrote:winner-within wrote:I agree, Dickinson Trinity, Bishop Ryan, Oak Grove and such, along with Valley City they should all be in Class A and stay there until they get to 100 or less total in HS, then it would equal things out to the 150 to 200's drawing from 1,000 to 2,000 people....Great point, great analysis!
Wow, let your dim light shine brother.............
The Schwab wrote:Region 1- Fargo Oak Grove- 195 (7-12) 32.5 kids per class
Region 2- Grafton- 265 (9-12) 66.25 kids per class
Region 3- Linton- 124 (9-12) 31 kids per class
Region 4- North Star- 82 (9-12) 20.5 kids per class
Region 5- Standing Rock- 238 (7-12) 39.67 kids per class
Region 6- Bishop Ryan- 251 (7-12) 41.83 kids per class
Region 7- Dickinson Trinity- 160 (7-12) 26.7 kids per class (I'm 99 percent sure this number is low)
Region 8- New Town- 215 (9-12) 53.75 kids per class
I don't think these enrollment numbers represent "Class B". Some of these schools have more kids in one class then most class b schools have in their entire high school. Just my two cents.
larrybird33 wrote:The Schwab wrote:Region 1- Fargo Oak Grove- 195 (7-12) 32.5 kids per class
Region 2- Grafton- 265 (9-12) 66.25 kids per class
Region 3- Linton- 124 (9-12) 31 kids per class
Region 4- North Star- 82 (9-12) 20.5 kids per class
Region 5- Standing Rock- 238 (7-12) 39.67 kids per class
Region 6- Bishop Ryan- 251 (7-12) 41.83 kids per class
Region 7- Dickinson Trinity- 160 (7-12) 26.7 kids per class (I'm 99 percent sure this number is low)
Region 8- New Town- 215 (9-12) 53.75 kids per class
I don't think these enrollment numbers represent "Class B". Some of these schools have more kids in one class then most class b schools have in their entire high school. Just my two cents.
I provided 160 as the enrollment for Trinity in grades 9-12.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests