Best Goalie in the State

[Sportshound]

We all have to wait and see.

Groves- gets a nod-- due to his third yr. as Varsity goalie

Arnason-  is very good

Kovacs- dicky goalie is excellent--//  with Otto as another very good G-man(and those two have to figure out who will be #1.

GFC-  Simmers heir to the spot. Not to proven

Fargo North-- ouch-- but have young talent Aikens kid

Fargo South-  Kelly--  tops on JV for South for two yrs. Back-up to Diechert last yr. he'll have to prove himself.

West fargo-- good backstopper-- K. Keller-- will have to stand on his head this year--(again)

Jamestown--  have a couple of young kids-- they could be solid in pipes

Others-- Not to much to talk about

[Centralhockey_08]

Arnason-  is very good

GFC-  Simmers heir to the spot. Not to proven

First off I wouldn't call Arnason very good, he is above average. I would be willing to be the Starting goalie for GFC is:> ) to be Seth Lang who will be one of the top goalies in the state by the time he is a senior...  

[Centralhockey_08]

Any predictions who the best goalie in the state will be this year?

It isn't going to be the goalie from R.R. :dude:

[Centralhockey_08]

A goalie gets much better when they get 30+ shots a game.

Arnason/Diechert, when they only get 10-15 shots a game, imo just makes it that much harder, especially to get a good save %. Going from getting 0 shots in the last 30 minutes to having to face a breakaway is incredibly tough on goalies, and at the state tournament when the goalies faced a lot of shots it wasn't what they were used to. However, had they played in the west all year, I'm sure they would have done much better.

How about Arnason letting in 3 goals on about 12 shots against Williston during the State hockey tourney. Now that is telling.

[Favre#1]

Arnason is still gunna be good...you can't say he's not gunna be

[jkaiz]

hes good because of his defense...

[brownbomber]

We all have to wait and see.

Groves- gets a nod-- due to his third yr. as Varsity goalie

Arnason-  is very good

Kovacs- dicky goalie is excellent--//  with Otto as another very good G-man(and those two have to figure out who will be #1.

GFC-  Simmers heir to the spot. Not to proven

Fargo North-- ouch-- but have young talent Aikens kid

Fargo South-  Kelly--  tops on JV for South for two yrs. Back-up to Diechert last yr. he'll have to prove himself.

West fargo-- good backstopper-- K. Keller-- will have to stand on his head this year--(again)

Jamestown--  have a couple of young kids-- they could be solid in pipes

Others-- Not to much to talk about

Fargo North-- ouch-- but have young talent Aikens kid- hes not very good has the talent but hes really lazy and is not very consistant. 

[brownbomber]

Arnason-  is very good

GFC-  Simmers heir to the spot. Not to proven

First off I wouldn't call Arnason very good, he is above average. I would be willing to be the Starting goalie for GFC is:> ) to be Seth Lang who will be one of the top goalies in the state by the time he is a senior...  

 the lang is injury prone

[Centralhockey_08]

Arnason-  is very good

GFC-  Simmers heir to the spot. Not to proven

First off I wouldn't call Arnason very good, he is above average. I would be willing to be the Starting goalie for GFC is:> ) to be Seth Lang who will be one of the top goalies in the state by the time he is a senior...  

 the lang is injury prone

Oh really and your basing this on what? I don't know of him having any injuries the last two years. He was sick but he wasn't injured. Still will be starting over Simmers.

[HockeyHigh]

As I've said before, the West isn't the strongest point of my high school hockey knowledge in ND, but I believe that Groves will be the stand-out, but won't have the team to make them compete for the state championship. Otherwise I see a goalie coming out of Fargo South (their team will make their goalie do well if he isn't himself, ie Diechert got a good save % because his team kept shots out of the house) or Arnason taking all the bacon for goalie talk this year. Of course I'm sure there are great west goalies too (Kovacs) but they won't get that much attention because of the team they play for, just like Groves. Team success is directly proportional to a team's attention. ;)

[ndhockey11]

I dont see how you people can argue who is the best goalie in the state?? Even with Red Rivers "Great Team and Great Defense" Arnason is the best goalie in the state without a question. He recently played in the Minnesota Elite League where he was the only north dakota goalie even asked to try out for the team and on top of that he finished the elite season ranked 5th out of 17 goalies. The elite league is 10 times better competition then ND high school hockey and he still manages to be a top goalie in that league. Take a look for yourselves:

http://www.hselitehockey.com

1. WI 35 Sand Brady Eau ClaireMemorial G 264.9 0.928 2.265
2. NE 23 Phillippi Joseph Hill-Murray G 860.8 0.919 2.997
3. SW 1 Caschetta Derrick Edina G 899.1 0.897 3.203
4. WI 1 Martin Andrew Stoughton G 716.9 0.888 3.431
5. GP 1 Arnason Pat G.F. Red River G 731.2 0.869 4.103

[HockeyHigh]

Whether or not you think the Elite league is better than ND HS hockey by 10x (Which I don't believe, it may be high quality hockey, but it's not 10x better). I'm not impressed with an 86.9% save average and a GAA of 4.1. These could be the best players in the NHL, and if you're as good as they are, you should have save percents in accordance. I'm sure there are other goalies in ND that could put up the same or better save %'s in this situation.

[ndhockey11]

You must not know the competeition in the Elite league very well. There are around 120 players and out of those players 50 or so already have Division 1 scolarships. If you take a look at the other goalies in the league, no goalie had AMAZING stats. It is a very offensive league, where each goalie sees 30, 40 and even 50 shots a game. I dont believe that there is any other goalie in the state that could crack the top 5 goalies in that league besides him. He has proven himself over and over again.

-2007 ND state Championship SV% 94 GAA 1.11 http://ndhighschoolhockey.com/
-2007 National Chamionship U16 Tier II SV% 94 GAA 1.37 http://edit.usahockey.com/2007_national ... 216u_stat/
-2007 Select 17's festival goalie SV% 92 GAA 1.2, 5th out of all goalies in the Nation http://www.usahockey.com/uploadedFiles/ ... ltenders(2).html
-2007 Elite league goalie SV% 87 GAA 4.1 http://www.hselitehockey.com

Please let me know what other goalie in the state that can accomplish that many achievements in one year. I dont think there is another goalie that can. I think that if there is one goalie in the state to go on to JUNIOR A after high school it will be him and then on to play Division 1 hockey after that. He has proven himself over and over even outside of ND High School hockey. He is the best goalie in the state with or with out his good team.

[HockeyHigh]

You say that he's good with or without a good team. But all of his quality stats come from when he is on a team that excels great amounts over most of the rest of the competition. Also in the Elite league, although you may argue they have better teams, the top goalies have far better statistics than he does. However you put the league, I believe you're building him up to more than he is by all his fancy shmancy statistics. He will have good statistics, just like DIechert did last year, but that doesn't make you a great goalie, does it? As far as statistics go, he could be a complete headcase and crumple after a goal is scored on him, or be the most consistent goalie in the world.

[Sportshound]

arnason is a good goalie.
his stats-- posted by ND Hockey11-- show he plays at a high level.

They are good not great.- he on the other hand has proven he can compete and if he plans on playing beyond HS he will need to continue to grow ,learn and get better at that grueling position.


As far as having some good teams in front of him-- Red river is a good team, the Elite team--must have been good also(especially with the talent level of players on that Great Plains team) even: Just the North Dakota boys listed- Meland, Ledoucer, Demers, Powers, Narveson, Groth, Hills, Galbreath,Siminson, Schaefer--- are all top notch players in this state.
then add in the Minnesota boys-- wow-- that was a team in front of him. So his numbers were not as good as during the regular season, but the point was made-- Many D1 signed players int he Elite League, many more than what Team Great plains had/has.
Or maybe I am not informed-- but I think only Ness(Roseau) is a committ to Minnesota, Verbals by Ravndalen(Warroad), oliver(Roseau)- to st. Cloud.
No others that I could see on the team list have signed or committed.

So they played teams with tons of D1 players. figure it out-- top players(D1 Caliber) playing non-committs-- Hmmm going to be some goals scored...

Now the Best goalie in the State ND-- might be on a team that doesn't hardly win a game-- Dickinson, or Devils Lake.

Good luck to all the players this year-- keep posting your responses it is fun to hear everyones ideas, positions on what they see.

[HockeyHigh]

I completely support that Arnason can be, and is a great goalie. But so was Diechert. I'm not saying he's not a good goalie, I'm simply saying that there are plenty of other goalies in the state that can be just as good as him, if not better.

[und52]

What about that Norweigen kid at Shanley?

[Riotmaker#9]

Ya I've heard about that Norweigan kid. The Shanley People call him Dr. Dre. With a name like that he better be a gangster between the pipes.

[HockeyHigh]

So you think he'll be able to keep South/RR under 15 goals this year?

[Sportshound]

15 goals?? wow not sure anyone in the state will score 15 goals in a game.
Wasn't it 20+ that South put up on Wapheton a few years ago.....???
I am sure that kind of a score will not be seen in this state again. Coaches and kids understand the problems that come with a drubbing like that. RR and south would be the ones to be able to do that.

The so called "Dr. Dre" of Shanley must be a standout to the faithful of Shanley, but can't imagine a goalie bringing his team, with out much punch, to the title... does anyone else think that a goalie and onlya goalie can do that?? who ever posted the nickname must be close to the situation- player?? for shanley???-- good luck boys.
Nov. 5th started a Whole New year in ND HS hockey. Let the fun begin.
goalies will be the topic on this thread-- and they still are in this order in my book--
tied at the Top:
groves- DL, kovacs- dickinson, arnason- RR, Keller- WF, Kelly-South
**maybe the kid from Mandan-- klien if he plays??? any word on that team-- New coach and all??
any others?? just listing the ones that will play top of their game this year-- i think.

[HockeyHigh]

The South championship team a few years ago (I believe they won state that year) attempted to make a statement by clobbering Whapeton somewhere between 26-0 and 28-0. I don't believe they even had their 1st or 2nd lines out after the first period. I can see RR or South doing that to Whapeton/Shanley or another team that is on a few piers below the best in the state.

[hockeyfan02]

After his performance in the state tournament last year, I would say Groves is probably at the top of the list.

[ghetto*revival]

hahah dre dog whats his real name

[Centralhockey_08]

Put arnason or deichert in the situation kline has they would get lite up just as bad.

That is because both goalies never face any shots.

[HockeyHigh]

Put arnason or deichert in the situation kline has they would get lite up just as bad.

That is because both goalies never face any shots.

And they're both headcases.